A recent case confirms that the NHS dispute resolution process is amenable to judicial review and also serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of adhering to contractual procedures for variation of contracts to incorporate new obligations into them.
The Court of Appeal has ruled that the determination of an NHS Resolution adjudicator carrying out statutory primary care contract dispute resolution functions on behalf of the Secretary of State is amenable to judicial review. The judgment overturns the decision at first instance and the precedent set in the High Court case of R (Haffiz) v NHS Litigation Authority [2020] EWHC 3792 (Admin).
Case background
The appellant, Dr Shashikanth, held two General Medical Services (GMS) contracts administered by NHS Hillingdon Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG). The CCG terminated the contracts, alleging a breach of the obligation to cooperate with a primary care network, as stipulated by paragraph 15A of Schedule 3 to the National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015 (as amended) (2015 Regulations).
Rather than challenging the notices through the civil courts, Dr Shashikanth chose to exercise his contractual right to refer the dispute to the Secretary of State (SoS) for determination under the statutory NHS dispute resolution process. The SoS delegated the dispute resolution function to the NHS Litigation Authority (NHS Resolution).
The NHS Resolution adjudicator upheld the terminations and Dr Shashikanth applied for judicial review, challenging both the adjudicator’s determination and the termination notices.
Decision at first instance
The High Court judge found that the adjudicator had erred in law by proceeding on the mistaken basis that paragraph 15A created an immediately effective requirement of co-operation and that Dr Shashikanth’s failure to comply with it constituted a breach of the contracts entitling the CCGs to terminate. However, he held that neither the adjudicator’s determination nor the termination notices were amenable to judicial review and so dismissed the claim.
Dr Shashikanth was granted permission to appeal the ruling on the adjudicator’s decision but not on the termination notices.
Court of Appeal
The Appeal Court found in favour of Dr Shashikanth.
Giving judgment, Lord Justice Lewis observed that judicial review is only available against a body exercising public functions and only then in respect of public law matters. He said that there are, broadly, two approaches to the question of whether a person or a body is exercising a public function:
- Source of power: if a person or body is exercising power derived from statute (or the prerogative, if the matter is justiciable) then the person or body is generally assumed to be exercising a public function.
- Nature of decision: the court may have regard to the nature of the function being performed to determine whether that function has a “sufficient public element” as to make it amenable to judicial review. Relevant considerations include but are not limited to:
- the extent of government or other public authority involvement in the function
- whether and to what extent the exercise of the function is performed against a background of statutory powers, and
- the nature and importance of the function
The Court concluded that in the current case, the SoS’s power is statutory, making the function inherently public and therefore the decision of the adjudicator was amenable to judicial review.
The issue of variation
The Court concluded that the contracts needed to be varied to incorporate the requirements at paragraph 15A of the Regulations. Though the CCG had sent Dr Shashikanth a letter informing him of the requirements of paragraph 15A, the letter had not constituted a contractual variation because it did not conform to the clauses of the contracts governing how a variation should be made. The CCG had, therefore, failed to vary the contracts, meaning the termination notices issued by it were based on a breach of a non-existent contractual obligation.
Relief
The Appeal Court determined that the determination of the adjudicator be quashed the matter be remitted to NHS Resolution to determine the dispute in accordance with the Court’s judgment, ie. on the basis that there had been no breach by the appellant of any obligation to co-operate with the primary care network because the two contracts had not been amended to include obligations equivalent to paragraph 15A.
Samuel Lindsay | Healthcare Lawyer | Mills & Reeve
Every piece of content Mills & Reeve create is correct on the date it’s published but please don’t rely on it as legal advice. If you’d like to speak about your own legal requirements, please contact Mills & Reeve.
